I watched The Bachlorette this evening. I usually don’t. There was nothing else on that caught my eye. Of the remaining three men who the Bachlorette really liked, she described Reid, as having difficulty forming his feelings into words. She determines to open him up on their full day together and asks him pointed questions. Some of them we hear and see his response too. This is a guy she obviously adores, she can hardly keep her hands off of him, she is constantly kissing and hugging him; they seem to laugh together all the time. She is right out there with her feelings for him.
I could see the frustration in his eyes. He kept grinning and hedging and making half-formed answers. I saw frustration and resistance in his eyes. I could also see her, almost physically trying to pull out of him a fully-fledged feeling. Something coherent that indicated he’d taken the time to know himself and analyse his own feelings and then figure out which words described them. But he really couldn’t, just a lot of grinning and hugging and kissing. To her credit she gave him praise for what he was able to share with her, which must have been enough, because they spent the night together. She said that she felt strong chemistry with him, enough to sleep with him. She also wanted another opportunity to have intimate talks, off camera, where he might be more able to express himself.
Then comes the end of the show and the rose ceremony, three men – two roses - someones going home. Watching her with all three, I couldn’t figure out how she could choose. Guess who went home? Reid, of the three the one who couldn’t TELL her how he felt and what he thought about.
In the limo being driven away and out of Jillian’s life, Reid is interviewed for the audience. He says, “I should have been able to tell her how I felt, I might be losing the one woman I should be with, etc., etc.” He is not smiling now, he actually looks uncharacteristically serious and introspective. As he spoke he became more regretful, and more resigned and a realization seemed to dawn on him that he had not tried hard enough to keep this woman. He didn’t realize until he lost her that he should have made more of an effort to tell her how he felt.
I felt a combination of sympathy and impatience towards him. How could he have gone through that whole program, those weeks after weeks of competition with the other guys, to get to the final three and then NOT realize how important, how critical it would be for him to use every possible moment to express himself to her. Notwithstanding that the whole concept of the show is stupid – just forget about that for the moment – but if this had occured in real life, and she’d been dating him and a few other guys at the same time, and he felt that way about her, wouldn’t he have made sure that she knew that he wanted to be exclusive with her?
As I watched this “mini-drama” unfold I couldn’t help but wonder: What makes some men think that they have no responsibility for knowing how to express what they feel? Are they raised with no ability to string an emotional phrase together? Or, are they so ego-driven that they simply won’t take the risk of using words to describe how they feel, because their goal is to be obtuse and equivocal. Do they really think that women can be strung along with platitudes and gestures? What does it take for them to “get real”? Does it require a Sports Illustrated model with a PhD and a bankroll, and they suddenly become emotionally verbal? Most men are sadly mistaken, because they are not going to find those women. They are going to meet women that are just as flawed and imperfect as they are.
I think women, including me, get a really bad wrap for talking too much and sharing too many feelings. I’ve been criticized for exposing perhaps more than anyone needs to know, just because I’m searching for the words that I need to express my feelings. Sometimes it is scary to tell someone just how vulnerable you are to them, but not telling them, puts the relationship at such a disadvantage. It seems to me that if you open up about where you are in the relationship and how you feel about the other person, you don’t have to spend a lot of wasted time hedging or pretending not to care about things – always in self-protective mode. If you both feel differently, isn’t that something to know? So that one person does not make an internal commitment that is not shared by the other?
I’ve strayed a little from my original observation. That men don’t seem to know how to express their feelings. I guess all of this rambling can be summed up by saying. How can a man feel justified in regretting a loss of love if he didn’t take it seriously enough to LEARN how to talk about it? And that sums up what is angering me right now. I’m tired, sick to death of the taciturn man, who mumbles one word answers to your desire to discuss the secrets of the Universe. It’s boring and it’s disrespectful. It shows me that he doesn’t take me or my company seriously enough, or with enough pleasure to engage me in a conversation, even if it’s about nothing. I’m not saying he has to talk for hours on end, but being able to hold a conversation for a half an hour and talk about something that might not be his most favorite subject or might seem irrelevant or insignificant shouldn’t be too much to ask. Being able to talk about the future in the abstract, with no strings attached, no promises, no inferences of commitment, but having fun with it in the context of “us” would be enjoyable and refreshing.
I really hope I meet that guy one day. I won’t hold my breath.
